Immunity of Defense and Allegation of Insult
The Bar Association decision, which evaluated the statements in the appeal petition within the scope of the immunity of defense, was upheld.
Summary
In the complaint of insult filed due to the statements used by the respondent attorney in the appeal petition, it was decided that the words remained within the limits of defense. The Union of Turkish Bar Associations (TBB) Disciplinary Board stated that, when the text is evaluated as a whole, the statements do not carry criminal intent and aim to explain the client's position. Consequently, the Bar Association decision stating that there is no room for imposing a disciplinary penalty on the respondent attorney was upheld.
The Facts
It was alleged that the statements used by the respondent attorney in an appeal petition submitted on behalf of their client contained an insult against the opposing colleague.
Assessment
The Board emphasized that the allegation of insult should be evaluated taking into account the entire petition and the whole case, rather than through a single sentence. It was accepted that the expressions used to explain the client's intent and the nature of the incident during the performance of the defense duty did not carry an intent to insult and remained within the limits of defense.
Key Terms
- Savunma Sınırları
- The area of freedom of expression that an attorney possesses while conducting professional activities and representing the client before judicial authorities, which does not exceed the rule of good faith.
- Disiplin Cezası Tayinine Yer Olmadığı
- The decision rendered when, as a result of the examination conducted, it is determined that the attorney's action does not constitute a disciplinary offense or that the offense has not occurred.
Follow Turkish legal developments
REGAS summarizes Turkish court and disciplinary decisions in plain language and notifies you.
The REGAS app is currently Turkish-only. If you would like English in the app, the best way to make it happen is to support the developer: get the app and just say so.
Outcome
It was decided to uphold the decision of the Bar Association Disciplinary Board and that there is no room for imposing a disciplinary penalty.