Fine Imposed on Lawyer Who Insulted Colleague
A lawyer who used offensive statements against a colleague was fined, taking into account recidivism provisions.
Summary
In the petition submitted to the court, the respondent lawyer used statements directed at their colleague representing the opposing party that were offensive, exceeded the legal boundaries of defense, and lacked objectivity. The warning penalty issued by the Bar Disciplinary Board was converted into a fine by applying recidivism provisions due to the nature of the act and the lawyer's prior disciplinary penalties. The TBB Disciplinary Board affirmed the decision as amended, confirming that the statements violated the rules of the profession.
The Facts
Disciplinary proceedings were initiated against the respondent lawyer on the allegation of insulting their colleague representing the opposing party in a petition submitted to a civil lawsuit by making accusations such as "talking big" and "opportunist."
Assessment
It was determined that the statements used by the respondent lawyer against their colleague in the court petition fell outside the legal boundaries of the right of defense and offended the colleague. It was stated that the act constituted a violation of Articles 5 and 27/1 of the TBB Rules of the Profession. Since the respondent had prior finalized disciplinary penalties, it was ruled that the recidivism provisions of the Attorneyship Law must be applied, and the warning penalty issued by the board of first instance was insufficient and had to be converted into a fine.
Rules Violated
- Attorneys' Act (No. 1136) art. 34
- Attorneys' Act (No. 1136) art. 135/2
- Attorneys' Act (No. 1136) art. 136/2
- Attorneys' Act (No. 1136) art. 157/6
- TBB Professional Rules art. 5
- TBB Professional Rules art. 27/1
Key Terms
- Tekerrür
- The aggravation of a penalty in the event that a previously penalized lawyer commits a similar or different disciplinary offense within a specified period of time.
- Objektiflik İlkesi
- The obligation of a lawyer to demonstrate an objective, fair, and rule-compliant stance in their professional activities, independent of the case to which they are a party.
Follow Turkish legal developments
REGAS summarizes Turkish court and disciplinary decisions in plain language and notifies you.
The REGAS app is currently Turkish-only. If you would like English in the app, the best way to make it happen is to support the developer: get the app and just say so.
Outcome
It was ruled that a fine be imposed on the respondent lawyer.